Comparison of Economy of COD-5B vs PVC for
500 meters of COD 110mm(O.D.) with 90mm(I.D.) : 5 subducts of 28/33mm
500 meters of PVD 100mm(O.D.) with 90mm(I.D.) : 3 subducts of 28/33mm

US$1=\1,140
Unit : US$
Work Description
Calculation/
Job description
Unit
Qty
man/day
Unit
Cost
Amount
Remarks
1.Matrial:
A. PVC Ducting  
    System
   1)Outer Duct
   2)Inner Duct
   3)Coupler



PVC(100/90mm)
HDPE tube(28/33)
Or coupling material



6m
m
Piece



84
1,500
84



18.018
0.67
.



1513.474
998.6842
0
.
 
Total
     
2512.158
 
B. COD-5B
.
Outer Duct:90/110mm
Inner Duct:28/33mm
m
.
500
.
6.14
.
3070.175
.
Readily built-in
 
2. Installation
A. PVC
1)PVC Laying

2)Connection of Outer
    Duct
3 Insertion of 5 Inner
    Ducts
4)Cleaning of Outer
    Duct
For 500m of PVC 145mm Duct & 5*42.4mm Inner Ducts.


0.10M/D Per 6m
0.26M/D Per 6m
0.083M/D Per 6m
0.04M/D Per 6m
0.48M/D Per 100m
0.53M/D Per 100m
0.44M/D Per 100m
(0.6+0.34) Per 100m
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
(500m)
(500m)
(500m)
(500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
8.40
21.84
0
0
0.02
0.02
0.00
0.00
   
Total Pipe Layer
General Labor
Sub-total
 
8.42
21.86
30.28
64.48
45.94
542.9997
1004.45
1547.447

Inner Duct(3+2):440%
Total Conventional System
 
4059.605
 
Unit Cost of per linear meter of Inner Duct
 
2.706
US$/meter
B. COD
(for 5 Inner ducts:
2,500n)
Pipe Layer
General Labor
(500m)
(500m)
28.50
9.00
64.48
45.94
1837.70
413.48
0.018M/D Per 100m
0.057M/D Per 100m
  Sub-total  
37.50
 
2251.18
Practically:50% applicable
 
Total COD
     
5321.35
 
Unit Cost of per linear meter of Inner Duct
     
2.129
US$/meter


Comparison of Economy of COD-5B vs PVC for
500 meters of COD 110mm(O.D.) with 90mm(I.D.) : 5 subducts of 28/33mm
500 meters of PVD 145mm(O.D.) with 135mm(I.D.) : 5 subducts of 36.4/42.4mm

US$1=\1,140
Unit : US$
Work Description
Calculation/
Job description
Unit
Qty
man/day
Unit
Cost
Amount
Remarks
1.Matrial:
A. PVC Ducting  
    System
   1)Outer Duct
   2)Inner Duct
   3)Coupler



PVC(135/145mm)
HDPE tube(35.4/42.4)
Or coupling material



6m
m
Piece



84
2,500
84



58.772
0.921
.



4936.842
2302.632
0
Estimate only
 
Total
     
7239.474
 
B. COD-5B
.
Outer Duct:90/110mm
Inner Duct:28/33mm
m
.
500
.
7.35
.
3676.21
.
Readily built-in
 
2. Installation
A. PVC
1)PVC Laying

2)Connection of Outer
    Duct
3 Insertion of 5 Inner
    Ducts
4)Cleaning of Outer
    Duct
For 500m of PVC 145mm Duct & 5*42.4mm Inner Ducts.


0.12M/D Per 6m
0.32M/D Per 6m
0.083M/D Per 6m
0.04M/D Per 6m
0.48M/D Per 100m
0.53M/D Per 100m
0.44M/D Per 100m
(0.6+0.34) Per 100m
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
Pipe Layer
General Labor
(500m)
(500m)
(500m)
(500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
(2,500m)
10.08
26.88
0
0
0.021
0.023
0.00
0.00
   
Total Pipe Layer
General Labor
Sub-total
 
10.10
26.90
37.00
64.48
45.94
651.3273
1236.00
1887.322

Inner Duct(3+2):440%
Total Conventional System
     
9126.796
 
Unit Cost of per linear meter of Inner Duct
     
3.651
US$/meter
B. COD
(for 5 Inner ducts:
2,500n)
Pipe Layer
General Labor
(500m)
(500m)
28.50
9.00
64.48
45.94
1837.70
413.48
0.018M/D Per 100m
0.057M/D Per 100m
  Sub-total  
37.50
 
2251.18
Practically:50% applicable
 
Total COD
     
5927.39
Material+Installation
Unit Cost of per linear meter of Inner Duct
     
2.371
US$/meter